Nathan Bishop

[Leigh_Seasider]

I see Man U have signed another keeper, Bish needs some games under his belt so hopefully he’ll get them!

 

[Yorkshire Blue]

It was appointing Bond that was the huge mistake.

A mistake most of SZ backed as the right move.

 

[mfurok]

Unlikely to have been backed by those who went to Rochdale.

 

[Chrisb]

A mistake most of SZ backed as the right move.

I definitely didn't !

 

[brigg blue]

A mistake most of SZ backed as the right move.

I don't think the mistake was letting him have a crack when he earned it by keeping us up, the mistake was not replacing him once it became clear it was a fluke and having no-one lined up resulting in performing "financial gymnastics" for SC

 

[ESG]

I see Man U have signed another keeper, Bish needs some games under his belt so hopefully he’ll get them!

Just seen it's Tom Heaton from Villa. Keepers mature late as is an example with Heaton so loads of time Bish, just stick with it and that great attitude.

 

[tottenham541]

Be interesting to know how highly and how much they rate Bishop at the moment, say when his season loan spell ends at Mansfield and they want to sign him on a permanent deal as to what the chances will be and how much it would cost ?

 

[RHB]

I would absolutely love to see Bishop make the grade at United as first choice. Sadly, as with so many other young british players signed from other clubs, it could end with a permanent transfer to a lower league club. Mind you, if that happens, then the Prem coaching and experience will be something to remember and set him up for a solid professional career.

 

[Bearded Shrimper]

I would absolutely love to see Bishop make the grade at United as first choice. Sadly, as with so many other young british players signed from other clubs, it could end with a permanent transfer to a lower league club. Mind you, if that happens, then the Prem coaching and experience will be something to remember and set him up for a solid professional career.

they took their time with Henderson didn't they? So could be looking for Bishop to follow a similar path and timeline

 

[OllieSteph44]

Bishop on the bench for Man U today at Derby County…..and Hutchinson on the bench for Derby!

Good to see

 

[Linda Loan Shark]

they took their time with Henderson didn't they? So could be looking for Bishop to follow a similar path and timeline

When Henderson was Bishops age he was already playing Championship football and at 22 premier league football. Bishop was on loan to a league two club so completely different.

He won't make it in the Premiership but as someone said with that sort of coaching experience he will improve a lot

 

[RHB]

Bishop on the bench for Man U today at Derby County…..and Hutchinson on the bench for Derby!

Good to see

better still if they get minutes during the game.

 

[Bearded Shrimper]

When Henderson was Bishops age he was already playing Championship football and at 22 premier league football. Bishop was on loan to a league two club so completely different.

He won't make it in the Premiership but as someone said with that sort of coaching experience he will improve a lot

might be they seem Bishop as a later developer. I don't see him as a Prem keeper, but I doubt they'd buy him just to move on to a lower level. could be, but seems slightly odd

 

[OllieSteph44]

Bish didn’t get on. Hutchinson played 30 mins and assisted Kazim Richards for the Derby goal.

Great to see the two guys share an embrace and chew the fat about Southend days afterwards ?

 

[londonblue]

might be they seem Bishop as a later developer. I don't see him as a Prem keeper, but I doubt they'd buy him just to move on to a lower level. could be, but seems slightly odd

Why not? They can buy him for peanuts and progress him in the hope that he makes the 1st team. If not then they can sell him either for a profit or not. The kind of loss they may make is also peanuts to them, but the chances are that, if it doesn't work out, they'll sell him to Championship club and make a bit of a profit. Frankly it's a gamble they can afford to take, and one that Bish would be mad not to take.

 

[Weston's left foot]

I thought Bishop had gone on loan to Mansfield?

 

[SS9_Shrimper]

He joins up with Mansfield nearer the start of the season. United need the numbers in for training camps whilst a lot of the squad are still on their holidays.

 

[Bearded Shrimper]

Why not? They can buy him for peanuts and progress him in the hope that he makes the 1st team. If not then they can sell him either for a profit or not. The kind of loss they may make is also peanuts to them, but the chances are that, if it doesn't work out, they'll sell him to Championship club and make a bit of a profit. Frankly it's a gamble they can afford to take, and one that Bish would be mad not to take.

just didn't think there would be the return if they sold him to a 2nd or 3rd tier club, but maybe there would be. depends what we got for him I suppose

 

[londonblue]

just didn't think there would be the return if they sold him to a 2nd or 3rd tier club, but maybe there would be. depends what we got for him I suppose

I don't think they care about the return. To them it's a gamble they can afford to lose. If it happens to work out then all the better for them.

The fact that he's been with ManUre, however, will had a premium to any sales value.

 

[Bearded Shrimper]

I don't think they care about the return. To them it's a gamble they can afford to lose. If it happens to work out then all the better for them.

The fact that he's been with ManUre, however, will had a premium to any sales value.

fair points