The Final: Nevermind vs The Stone Roses

[Mad Cyril]

If Nirvana were so inspirational why do most of their fans loiter outside W H Smiths looking like miserable ****s?

 

[Ron Manager]

I Nirvana were so inspirational why do most of their fans loiter outside W H Smiths looking like miserable ****s?

:clap:

Fair point

 

[Pubey]

I Nirvana were so inspirational why do most of their fans loiter outside W H Smiths looking like miserable ****s?

great point, i would argue that all Nirvana have influenced is slackers, wasters and MTV-rock. I'm struggling to think of any music of note that has come from Nirvana/Nevermind/Grunge.

 

[Jedi Shrimper]

Voted for the Stone Roses.

Reasons:
- Nirvana made a better album than Nevermind, It's called In Utero.
- I prefer The Stone Roses debut to Nevermind.
- Waterfall. Quite possibly my favourite song ever.
- The bassline on I Am The Ressurection.
- While I'm sick to death of the Nevermind cover, I could look at John Squire's
Jackson Pollock inspired artwork every day 'til I die and still wouldn't tire of it.
- The added bonus of annoying some people who seem to think there is a right and
wrong with enjoying music. (ie Q readers).

 

[MK Shrimper]

Voted for the Stone Roses.

Reasons:
- Nirvana made a better album than Nevermind, It's called In Utero.
- I prefer The Stone Roses debut to Nevermind.
- Waterfall. Quite possibly my favourite song ever.
- The bassline on I Am The Ressurection.
- While I'm sick to death of the Nevermind cover, I could look at John Squire's
Jackson Pollock inspired artwork every day 'til I die and still wouldn't tire of it.
- The added bonus of annoying some people who seem to think there is a right and
wrong with enjoying music. (ie Q readers).

Thanks Johnny, much appreciated!

 

[MK Shrimper]

Need a bit of a Ressurection on this thread so I'm Banging The Drum, because This Is The One! Vote The Stone Roses, musically flawed but an absolute perfection of harmony that'd make your day go with a whizz!

Vote The Stone Roses for a better Shrimperzone!

 

[Napster]

Im abstaining. I cant stand either.

 

[Napster]

I take it you've seen this, Dave?

 

[The Big Shrimp]

I take it you've seen this, Dave?

Superb find!! Shame he doesn't live there!!

 

[manor15]

Well done Aberdeen Shrimper and Nirvana

 

[TBV_Dan]

Nevermind slips in front on 40 votes to The Stone Roses's 33 votes.

 

[MK Shrimper]

Looks like it's all over. Can't argue at second place (again!) - unlike OFAH (:puke), I love Nirvana and Nevermind and it is a close, close second to The Stone Roses.

So thanks to the 35 people that voted and for everyone's votes across the competition. Cheers to BlueBlood for organising it.

 

[Basildon Blue]

Don't think the stone roses will be able to catch nevermind now.

 

[SUFC Forever]

44-35 to Nevermind with just over three hours to go. Not over till it's over but TSR have a lot to do to catch it now.

Vote Nevermind, those who have yet to cast their votes and let justice be done.

To the person who PM'd me and said that "there was more to music than rawk", I say RAWK RULES OK!!!

 

[Mad Cyril]

Kurt Kobain was a dirty smackhead and no better than Nick Cotton in my opinion.

 

[SUFC Forever]

Kurt Kobain was a dirty smackhead and no better than Nick Cotton in my opinion.

Er, hate to tell you this Cyril but Nick Cotton, he doesn't actually exist...:)

 

[Numphgirl]

Well done to both AS for Nevermind and MK for The Stone Roses

decent number of votes

 

[Pubey]

this final result is an embarrassment for music.

*walks away*

 

[SUFC Forever]

this final result is an embarrassment for music.

*walks away*

Hardly. Well done Nevermind, just proves that class will out in the end.

Great win, AS - as Bill McLaren the rugby commentator used to say "They'll be rejoicing in Aberdeen tonight"...

RAWK RULES OKAY!!!

 

[MK Shrimper]

Hardly. Well done Nevermind, just proves that class will out in the end.

Thank god 37 people on this board aren't as blinkered and tone deaf as you.

Yes I love Nevermind but I can appreciate all styles of music.