• Welcome to the ShrimperZone forums.
    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which only gives you limited access.

    Existing Users:.
    Please log-in using your existing username and password. If you have any problems, please see below.

    New Users:
    Join our free community now and gain access to post topics, communicate privately with other members, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and free. Click here to join.

    Fans from other clubs
    We welcome and appreciate supporters from other clubs who wish to engage in sensible discussion. Please feel free to join as above but understand that this is a moderated site and those who cannot play nicely will be quickly removed.

    Assistance Required
    For help with the registration process or accessing your account, please send a note using the Contact us link in the footer, please include your account name. We can then provide you with a new password and verification to get you on the site.

Has this season been a failure for you?


  • Total voters
    215
Strangely I don't think it's a failure from the club's perspective, with our history in mind; a trip to Wembley being an obvious landmark. But from Sturrock's personal perspective it must rank as a failure, what with his supposed knowledge of what it takes to get teams promoted in this league (bearing in mind that comment was made at our lowest ebb when he first arrived) combined with his widely known 5 year Championship plan that now requires back to back promotions if he stays.

Personally I'd warily support a change at the top, because I believe he's lost something in recent months (LDV aside), and wonder whether our performance at Port Vale under Coughlan as opposed to our recent home performances is a sign of the direction the players see the club heading.

Obviously I say this without any inside knowledge at all.
 
I agree with this totally, but doesn't Coughlan's family still live up north?

I've no idea, but he's been here for three years now and with management seemingly on his agenda, we'd offer him a prime opportunity to come and cut his teeth at the ground level. If Sturrock left and Coughlan was overlooked, I'd say it's a safe bet that Coughlan would follow Luggy out of the door.

I thought it was interesting that Coughlan had Luke Bonner assisting him at Port Vale though. He was assisting Ricky Duncan with the U18s and younger age groups a couple of years ago, so I imagine Sturrock and/or Coughlan think highly of him. Of course, after the cuts to the coaching team a few years back there's probably nobody else for that role, but I like the sense that there could be burgeoning familiarity or line-of-command at the club. Coughlan taking over from Sturrock, with Harris or Bonner taking on more responsibilities, would instigate change without the need of a revolution that would set us back seasons.
 
League home results have obviously been massively disappointing. However, we are going to Wembley, something we have all been waiting so long for. The season can't be deemed a failure for that alone. Hopefully, next season we will start well and then some more of the 30,000 who are going to Wembley will come along to League games too.
 
League home results have obviously been massively disappointing. However, we are going to Wembley, something we have all been waiting so long for. The season can't be deemed a failure for that alone. Hopefully, next season we will start well and then some more of the 30,000 who are going to Wembley will come along to League games too.

And come April 8th what have we got to look forward too?
 
And come April 8th what have we got to look forward too?

Errrm Bristol Rovers at home on Fri 12th?...which will be a meaningless game for both sides.

Oh.

:hilarious:
 
Wembley. A day out it will be and a bloody great one at that.

But that is all it is, a day.

As someone who has hardly been this season, I was hoping for promotion to help me get the buzz back fresh for next season. We have blown that.

I want to look forward to going every week. But I am afraid another season in League 2 will dampen the little enthusiasm I have left. I am sure I am not alone in that sense.

Do I want to feel this way?...Christ no. This is my club that I have followed all over the country for 25+ years. Time and commitments have not allowed me to attend as many away games in the last few years, as I would of liked, up until this season. But, this season I am ashamed to say I have not attended as much, more out of choice than anything else.

I am not happy with anything at my club. From top to bottom. I want change, a fresh start and a new lease of life. We are going nowhere fast. I feel like my club is dying a slow death. You try and put on a brave face, but you know its all academic in the end. My energy has been sapped, my love is still there, but I cannot bring it to the surface at the moment.

Yes I know as a "Supporter" I should be there whatever and I have been up until this season. I know that. But I cannot get that buzz back. I have tried believe me and Wembley will help. But I know that this is just a fairytale sideshow to what has been another horror story of a season.

As a Southend fan, perhaps we have no right to expect football on a regular basis, at a higher level. But christ, that does not mean we should just sit back and accept it. Does it?

I want to see us run out against better sides, in better stadiums on a weekly basis. Something to keep the interest up. And I was hoping we would achieve that this year. Is that me being selfish?

The bread and butter is the league. We needed to get out of the basement this season. We haven't. That for me means this season is a complete failure. I am sure Ronald would agree. My fear now is how the hell are we going to survive through the summer?....Season card take ups will no doubt be at their lowest level for many years. Will the better players leave?...Will we have another manager?

Everything points to another summer of complete and utter turmoil. No money, court appearances, embargo's, high player turnover and a new manager coming in having to work a miracle under even more abysmal conditions. It is like ****ing groundhog day and I am sick of it. Things need to change and quickly. But who the bloody hell is going to wave the magic wand?...nobody. That is the most depressing thing about it. We are stuck in a massive rut of complete crapness, with no way out, or no hope for the forseeable. And that is why I feel completely and utterly helpless.

The town has United for a cup final, no surprises there. But it clearly does not give a flying **** about it on a weekly basis. That is the problem and that is why a complete change is needed. Failure to do so and we will rot in the basement for many years to come.

What is the answer?...god knows. But I know this club needs change. Starting at the top. The town and the majority of the regular supporters, have total zero confidence in the board. That is a fact. Until that changes, we will continue on this merry-go-round of failed potential. The time has come for the board to be honest with themselves and admit failure. They do not have the means and perhaps the passion to drive us forward anymore. New owners, fresh investment and a renewed energy is required. But again, where the frig is it coming from?

It's all bloody dead ends, that is my whole point. No way out. And that is the single most sad thing for me.

To any member of the board reading this. Do the right thing and seek a way out of this hell hole. Not only for the fans, but for yourselves.


Agree with all of this.

Even more of a failure for me is, its become more of a chore going to games. Quite simply, if you're company were losing regular business/customers, and as a result you as a businessman were suffering financially, it would be quite drastic. Maybe even a failure. But there's not much you can do to get those regulars back, spending money with your company, if they've been disillusioned by how the company is run & it's moral ethics.
 
Last time we beat our hated local rivals to clinch our first cup final appearance at a major stadium and were drawn against Chelsea in the cup but lost the replay I think it was considered on balance a good season despite the woeful home record.
 
Bar winning 7 games in a row and thats not going to happen its a failure ... Luggy is part to blame and so is Ron and Smiffy is right even if we change manager at the end of the season its not getting any better because the be all and end all is the financial situation until that changes by ground development etc thing will not get better

Dont get me wrong Wembley is great but when the day trippers have gone and those off us who go week in week out turn up on a freezing cold November night I was hoping that it would not be against Torquay again .. no disrespect to them by the way but I thought we would be in the play offs at least

Will I be there yes because I love my club but we need some honesty clarity and above all someone who can sort out the financial situation otherwise we will never start to go forward
 
Wembley. A day out it will be and a bloody great one at that.

But that is all it is, a day.

As someone who has hardly been this season, I was hoping for promotion to help me get the buzz back fresh for next season. We have blown that.

I want to look forward to going every week. But I am afraid another season in League 2 will dampen the little enthusiasm I have left. I am sure I am not alone in that sense.

Do I want to feel this way?...Christ no. This is my club that I have followed all over the country for 25+ years. Time and commitments have not allowed me to attend as many away games in the last few years, as I would of liked, up until this season. But, this season I am ashamed to say I have not attended as much, more out of choice than anything else.

I am not happy with anything at my club. From top to bottom. I want change, a fresh start and a new lease of life. We are going nowhere fast. I feel like my club is dying a slow death. You try and put on a brave face, but you know its all academic in the end. My energy has been sapped, my love is still there, but I cannot bring it to the surface at the moment.

Yes I know as a "Supporter" I should be there whatever and I have been up until this season. I know that. But I cannot get that buzz back. I have tried believe me and Wembley will help. But I know that this is just a fairytale sideshow to what has been another horror story of a season.

As a Southend fan, perhaps we have no right to expect football on a regular basis, at a higher level. But christ, that does not mean we should just sit back and accept it. Does it?

I want to see us run out against better sides, in better stadiums on a weekly basis. Something to keep the interest up. And I was hoping we would achieve that this year. Is that me being selfish?

The bread and butter is the league. We needed to get out of the basement this season. We haven't. That for me means this season is a complete failure. I am sure Ronald would agree. My fear now is how the hell are we going to survive through the summer?....Season card take ups will no doubt be at their lowest level for many years. Will the better players leave?...Will we have another manager?

Everything points to another summer of complete and utter turmoil. No money, court appearances, embargo's, high player turnover and a new manager coming in having to work a miracle under even more abysmal conditions. It is like ****ing groundhog day and I am sick of it. Things need to change and quickly. But who the bloody hell is going to wave the magic wand?...nobody. That is the most depressing thing about it. We are stuck in a massive rut of complete crapness, with no way out, or no hope for the forseeable. And that is why I feel completely and utterly helpless.

The town has United for a cup final, no surprises there. But it clearly does not give a flying **** about it on a weekly basis. That is the problem and that is why a complete change is needed. Failure to do so and we will rot in the basement for many years to come.

What is the answer?...god knows. But I know this club needs change. Starting at the top. The town and the majority of the regular supporters, have total zero confidence in the board. That is a fact. Until that changes, we will continue on this merry-go-round of failed potential. The time has come for the board to be honest with themselves and admit failure. They do not have the means and perhaps the passion to drive us forward anymore. New owners, fresh investment and a renewed energy is required. But again, where the frig is it coming from?

It's all bloody dead ends, that is my whole point. No way out. And that is the single most sad thing for me.

To any member of the board reading this. Do the right thing and seek a way out of this hell hole. Not only for the fans, but for yourselves.

Well would he? We have these rumours that Ron is not happy or at least purports to be disatisfied with our performances. Luggy looks as though he has failed to deliver promotion this year but he has got us to a final that will supposedly allow us to balance our books this year. I honestly wonder, if given the choice, what Ron would choose, a money-making day at Wembley or promotion to League One???
Promotion was supposed to accompany our move to FF, or run just before it. Does Ron really want promotion just yet? when clearly the new stadium is still, at least, a couple of seasons away. OK promotion would increase our gates a bit but wouldn't it saddle us with more expenses, which Ron would not exactly welcome at the moment.
So, the question is; Does Ron consider this season a success or a failure? It's an answer we should have in a month or so's time.
 
I just do not see how your club playing in a cup final at wembley can be considered a failure, we as a club are in no fit state to get promoted from the chairman to the players (especially injuries) we are not league one material, get over it and remember this was the season we saw little southend walk out at wembley with 30k southenders in attendance, failure????? do me a favour.
 
Despite the fact it's looking very unlikely we won't make the playoffs, by the looks of it this fact cheers some of you up tremendously. It's not actually over yet. I always say it, it's not acceptable for the players to give up so why should it be acceptable for us to give up? Just a thought.

I go to football because I want to and I want to hope that we can still do it! So that's what I'm gonna do, anyone who questions this prerogative have clearly misunderstood what it means to support a small pointless league two club.
 
The aim at the start of the season, like last season, was to get promotion so from that point of view it has been a failure. But then 20 other teams in the division won't get promotion either. I think up until the turn of the year we were doing pretty well, especially considering we lost our star players in the summer. We've had a 14-game unbeaten run and some very impressive away wins this season (Rotherham, Vale, Chesterfield, Cheltenham), plus three wins against League One sides and being one game away from an FA Cup tie against Chelsea. Our downfall has been dropping points at home against the lower teams, as it was last season to a lesser extent. The last 3 home games have epitomised that and have probably killed our season off. But we've also been unlucky with injuries to key players (Timlin, Tomlin, Laird, Phillips), which have exposed our lack of depth. We've not really had a settled team since Christmas. Not to mention the never-ending financial problems, which hopefully the cup final will ease a bit.

I agree with leeblue: if we finish the season with our first ever domestic trophy then I don't think it can be considered a failure. A cup final at Wembley with 30,000 Shrimpers there will be a day to remember and would be a great gift from Sturrock if he does leave at the end of the season. Of course I would take promotion over winning the JPT but another top 10 finish and a cup final certainly doesn't constitute a terrible season. And at least there's a chance we might be playing Col U next season!
 
Yes, yes and yes. Another season in L2 has to be seen as a failure.
RM has made it very clear that the clubs ambition is to get out of this league and back to the championship :hilarious:

getting to Wembley is fantastic but, it is the league we should be concentrating on.
I am just fearful that come the 7th April when the cameras will be on us that we will dish up the pile of s**t we have had to watch at the last two home games
 
The way I see it, is that this season's objective was automatic promotion, or least a minimum of play-offs. This hasn't been achieved, therefore the season has been a failure.

Overcoming Orient in particular and getting to Wembley has been brilliant and it'll live long in the memory, but that wasn't the objective.
 
I just do not see how your club playing in a cup final at wembley can be considered a failure, we as a club are in no fit state to get promoted from the chairman to the players (especially injuries) we are not league one material, get over it and remember this was the season we saw little southend walk out at wembley with 30k southenders in attendance, failure????? do me a favour.

On the face of it I agree with you.However the bread and butter of the club is the league.Wembley is a result but its a day out for the fans nothing more nothing less - most people dont even care that much if we win or loose.
 

ShrimperZone Sponsors

FFM MSPFX Foreign Exchange Services
Estuary MFF2
Zone Advertisers Zone Advertisers

ShrimperZone - SUFC Player Sponsorship

Southend United Away Travel


All At Sea Fanzine


Back
Top