Bromley Blue
The artist formerly known as the_saafender
Grant is a good player but he is more replaceable than someone like Hall.
Saying he was the standout player in the playoffs is not saying much at all, the team was poor for 3 of the 4 halves.
Looking over the last season I would say Phillips, Clohessey and Hall stood out far more and whilst I would have liked Grant to stay I would rather lose him than those three.
I disagree. I think saying that Grant was the standout player in the playoffs is of importance. Yes a lot of the team played poorly and I'm in agreement with that. But there's also something to be said for having someone in the side who can perform in the big games and not let the nerves and pressure get the better of them. For me Hall fell into this category against Crewe and at other times during the season when we really needed him to perform. In a way by saying this I'm agreeing with your point about Hall as he is the catalyst for most of the good attacking play we do as the main player with some creativity in the side. But maybe its this (albeit arguable) inability to turn it on when it really matters is why we haven't (knowingly) had any big offers for Hall yet?
And yes those three did stand out more over the course of this season. This season wasn't one of Granty's best as he was in and out of the side but I stand by the belief that he could play higher than any of those 3. Hall may be up for debate but I think better defenders could keep him quiet a lot more often.