Question whats our strongest team with everyone one fit?

[Neil 24]

A luxury folks no injuries whats our best 11?

 

[Kris]

Smith

Clohessy
Cresswell
Phillips
Barker

Hurst
Mkandawire
Laird
Timlin

Assombalonga
Tomlin

When you look at that it's little wonder our season has stuttered badly at crucial times.

 

[Gremlin]

One fit what?

 

[Neil 24]

One fit what?

Slight **** up.

 

[Neil 24]

Smith

Clohessy
Cresswell
Phillips
Barker

Hurst
Mkandawire
Laird
Timlin

Assombalonga
Tomlin

When you look at that it's little wonder our season has stuttered badly at crucial times.

id go with this 11 to.

 

[silentshrimper]

Smith

Clohessy
Cresswell
Phillips
Barker

Hurst
Mkandawire
Laird
Timlin

Assombalonga
Tomlin

When you look at that it's little wonder our season has stuttered badly at crucial times.

You can't really disagree with this side...Corr pushing for a place up front

 

[tottenham541]

where"s bilel ?:smile:

 

[Yorkshire Blue]

Smith
Clohessy Cresswell Prosser Straker
Hurst Laird Makandawire Timlin
Tomlin Corr

Cresswell and Phillips are quite similar but we're better balanced with the quicker and left-footed Prosser playing with one of them. I suppose Mohsni could be an alternative to Prosser as he's got the talent but I'm not sure I trust him enough.

Assombalonga would come into the reckoning instead of Corr, particularly for away games.

 

[Somerset Ex-TTB]

Nobody knows, its never happened.

 

[BaileytheQuitter]

Nobody knows, its never happened.

Too right, hyper...

 

[Neil 24]

Nobody knows, its never happened.

With everyone fit who would you play?

 

[rlb999]

Smith

Clohessey
Cresswell
Prosser
Barker

Hurst
Mkandawire
Lund
Timlin

Tomlin
Assombalonga

Basically the team that went on the unbeaten run!

 

[Yorkshire Blue]

Smith

Clohessey
Cresswell
Prosser
Barker

Hurst
Mkandawire
Lund
Timlin

Tomlin
Assombalonga

Basically the team that went on the unbeaten run!

Do you mean Laird instead of Lund then?

 

[madaboutblues]

Phillips would definitely be in my team if fully fit. I'd go with the team Kris picked as well.

 

[Clinton Baptiste]

Phillips is our best defender. Glad some of you aren't manager!

 

[Norwichshrimper]

Smith
Clohessy Cresswell Prosser Straker
Hurst Laird Makandawire Timlin
Tomlin Corr

Cresswell and Phillips are quite similar but we're better balanced with the quicker and left-footed Prosser playing with one of them. I suppose Mohsni could be an alternative to Prosser as he's got the talent but I'm not sure I trust him enough.

Assombalonga would come into the reckoning instead of Corr, particularly for away games.

That's just bonkers - I'm not saying Prosser hasn't had a decent season but he is a lower league clogger whilst Phillips has a touch of class and when fit (which is what the original question was) he's by far our best defender. If anything Prosser is more similar to Cresswell than Phillips is, Phillips is a very good footballer

 

[Norwichshrimper]

A luxury folks no injuries whats our best 11?

Depends whether the play to the best of their ability or how they have been playing recently

 

[rlb999]

Phillips is our best defender. Glad some of you aren't manager!

Fair point actually. Heart over head. So Phillips is in, which unfortunately means that there's no place for Cresswell. This on the basis that Prosser has come on leaps and bounds whereas Cresswell is living on his reputation. Difficult choice though.

 

[dan_mays]

Everyone fit what does this mean LOL hasn't happened in a while but id go with;

Smith

Clohessy
Cresswell
Phillips
Barker

Leonard - Some may disagree but we look alot stronger with him in the side
Laird
Timlin
Hurst - Although he is out of form id rather him start than Moshni

Tomlin
Corr

Subs

Bentley, Prosser, Lund, Mkandwire, Moshni, Eastwood, Assombolonga

 

[Yorkshire Blue]

That's just bonkers - I'm not saying Prosser hasn't had a decent season but he is a lower league clogger whilst Phillips has a touch of class and when fit (which is what the original question was) he's by far our best defender. If anything Prosser is more similar to Cresswell than Phillips is, Phillips is a very good footballer

It's about picking your best team which isn't necessarily the same as picking the best individuals.

There's not much between Cresswell and Phillips in my opinion when both are fully fit. I don't have an issue with swapping those two. I've given Cresswell the benefit of the doubt that he's been playing injured because at his best he's been better IMO than Phillips at his best.

In what ways is Prosser more similar to Cresswell than Phillips is?