Carl Pettefer

davewebbsbrain · Jul 30, 2008

Straight Poll, no prompting from me...Would you have Petts Back

SUFC_Al · Jul 30, 2008

No, good work ethic and professional but mediocre on talent.

Ayrshire Blue · Jul 30, 2008

No, simple as

Shrimper2thecore · Jul 30, 2008

Was a very good player for us at the time, did what he needed to with little fuss, but has been out of the football league for a few years now, and I cant see him comming back stronger!

Matt the Shrimp · Jul 30, 2008

Solid L2 player. I'd have him back if our tw@ttish element at Roots Hall succeeded in hounding out Tilson - something which would, undoubtedly, see our eventual return to League 2.

:thump:

jerseyshrimper · Jul 30, 2008

Good on his day but league 2 at best now

OldBlueLady · Jul 30, 2008

Liked him, but as others have said, too long out of the hurly burly of the FL.

BoyWonder2 · Jul 30, 2008

Solid player, never let us down in League Two, but in terms of talent, I think League Two is about his level.

Andy_S · Jul 30, 2008

Not in a million years.

Clearly the heat is getting to people with suggestions about Pettefer and Nicolau coming back. There are reasons why they are both without clubs..................

davewebbsbrain · Jul 30, 2008

Andy_S said:
Not in a million years.

Clearly the heat is getting to people with suggestions about Pettefer and Nicolau coming back. There are reasons why they are both without clubs..................

Not the case, just had a chat with another poster who said I was the only one who would welcome him back, so I thought a poll was in order!

Ayrshire Blue · Jul 30, 2008

davewebbsbrain said:
Not the case, just had a chat with another poster who said I was the only one who would welcome him back, so I thought a poll was in order!

Well 13 other people agree with me.

davewebbsbrain · Jul 30, 2008

Ayrshire Blue said:
Well 13 other people agree with me.

Well that's 13 out of everyone on here...you specifically stated that NOBODY would vote to have him back apart from me..myself and 5 others have voted to say they would have him back...

So, to quote your good self..Back at ya son!!

Ayrshire Blue · Jul 30, 2008

davewebbsbrain said:
Well that's 13 out of everyone on here...you specifically stated that NOBODY would vote to have him back apart from me..myself and 5 others have voted to say they would have him back...

So, to quote your good self..Back at ya son!!

OK :unsure:

More people seem to agree with me than they do your good self.

davewebbsbrain · Jul 30, 2008

Ayrshire Blue said:
OK :unsure:

More people seem to agree with me than they do your good self.

I would agree with that point..but that wasn't your bold statement!!!

He won't be coming back here whatever we think anyway!!

Ayrshire Blue · Jul 30, 2008

davewebbsbrain said:
I would agree with that point..but that wasn't your bold statement!!!

He won't be coming back here whatever we think anyway!!

Good !!!:thump:

Jam_Man · Jul 30, 2008

Did well for us at the time but a poor mans alan McCormack.

We have far better midfielders than him here already.

SUFCLiam · Jul 30, 2008

I will say yes because at worst he can play for our res

Hazey · Jul 30, 2008

Did a reasonable job away at Tranmere a few seasons ago, if he was prepared to only play a few games a season and act purely as cover then yeah, another player that can play across the midfield if needs be would be good.